5 Comments
May 20Liked by Robert Talbert

Love this idea, especially as I look forward to tightening up elements of my grading system over the summer. A question: how do you figure out (at the beginning of the term) how many total credits are "available" or necessary to hit an A, B, etc.? Do you plan out all the different ways students can earn engagement credits, or do new opportunities for earning credits sort of pop up on the fly?

Expand full comment
author
May 21·edited May 21Author

Thanks Kim. I just play it by ear. I make sure 100 points is realistic and build the syllabus around that as a max. If we end up with more than 100, then that's all the better for students. If it's less, the syllabus says we'll refactor the grade levels appropriately. I have a few preset credit bearing options (class prep, attendance, startup assignment) but a lot of them were one-offs where I just thought "This would be a cool way to get engagement" and just put it out there.

Expand full comment
May 20Liked by Robert Talbert

I do something very similar - I call them "participation and preparation points", but I don't set different items to be worth different amounts. Reading (credited via perusall), attendance, in-class stuff, misc small homeworks, all are one point. (I might add "attend a relevant research talk in-person or online.") The threshold for an A is set at about 3/4 of the total available points (60 out of 80), for a B it's 50/80, and they're not required for any of the lower letter grades. (My institution doesn't have +- on undergrad grades, just whole letters.)

Expand full comment

I've always been intrigued with the notion of quest-based learning in the classroom, using Google Sheets to build a live leaderboard, and trying to gamify certain elements of my classroom. I even went so far as to try and use the Institute of Play's Quest Model with students. https://clalliance.org/institute-of-play/

I struggle with the daily management of it. I love the idea of being a 5th Grade Dungeon Master (DM) every day, but it feels like too much work to handle. Do you find that this is easier with your older students? Have you heard of Classcraft? https://www.classcraft.com/blog/how-use-dungeons-dragons-classroom/

All of these paid options seem great, but I could never afford a management system to help keep track of everyone's XP, along with their academic growth.

Expand full comment
author

I don't really want to pay for stuff. I just use Google Sheets and our LMS to track things. It's not hard, just boils down to spending 10-20 minutes a day on bookkeeping. Which is a weakness for me so I'm glad for the chance to work on it.

Expand full comment